August vs Yale Smart Locks: Which Is Better in 2026?
Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
August vs Yale smart locks: we compare the key differences, pros and cons side by side so you can decide which one is right for you. Updated for 2026.
The august vs yale smart lock decision comes down to one core question: do you want to keep your current deadbolt, or replace the whole lock? August builds locks that work with the deadbolt you already own, while Yale mostly sells complete locks that take its place. Both brands sit under the same parent company, so the apps and build quality feel closer than the marketing suggests. The comparison table below sums up the main differences at a glance.
Here is the quick answer. Choose August if you rent, want to keep your existing keys, or prefer the fastest possible install. Choose Yale if you want a built in keypad, a finished look on the outside of the door, and entry codes for family and guests. The sections that follow explain how that plays out in daily use.
August vs Yale Smart Locks: Comparison Table
The table below compares the two brands on the points that matter most to buyers, from lock style and installation to ongoing costs. Neither brand wins every row, which is why the right choice depends on your door, your household, and how much hardware you are willing to swap out.
| Criterion | August | Yale | Winner |
| Lock style | Adds on to your existing deadbolt | Replaces the full lock | Depends on your door |
| Outside of the door | Unchanged, your old key still works | New hardware, often with a keypad | August for renters |
| Entry codes | Needs a separate keypad accessory | Built into many models | Yale |
| Installation | About 10 minutes, one screwdriver | Longer, full lock swap | August |
| Ongoing costs | Core app features are free | Core app features are free | Tie |
| Best for | Rentals and quick upgrades | Owners who want codes | Tie |
What Is August? What Is Yale?
August overview
August made its name with locks that mount on the inside of your door and turn the deadbolt you already have. The outside of the door looks exactly as it did before, and your existing keys keep working as a backup. Control runs through the August app, with locking, unlocking, guest access, and an activity log. Because nothing changes outside, August became a favorite for renters and for anyone whose building controls the look of the front door.
Yale overview
Yale is one of the oldest lock makers in the world, and its smart range replaces the entire lock rather than adding to it. Most Yale smart locks include a keypad or touchscreen on the outside, so visitors can enter with a code instead of a phone or key. If you want a closer look at one current model, our yale assure lock 2 review covers the details. Yale suits owners who plan to stay put and want the door hardware fully renewed.
Key Differences
Reading the august vs yale smart lock comparison closely, five areas decide it for most households: how reliably the lock turns, which platforms it talks to, the install, the running costs, and how it protects your data. Price matters too, but mostly through the accessories each approach needs.
Reliability and Accuracy: August vs Yale
Both brands turn a deadbolt with a small motor, so accuracy depends more on your door than on the logo. A door that sticks in humid weather will strain either lock and drain batteries faster. August adds a door position sensor on its locks, which helps the app report whether the door is truly shut or just locked while ajar. Yale locks rely on the bolt itself and on correct alignment during setup. In practice, either brand proves reliable once the strike plate lines up well, and most complaints trace back to a misaligned door rather than the electronics.
Compatibility With Alexa, Google, HomeKit, and Matter: August vs Yale
August locks connect over Bluetooth at the door and reach your router through WiFi, either built in or through a small bridge. That setup works with Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple HomeKit on most current models. Yale sells its locks in several versions, some with a WiFi module included and some that need one added later, with support for the same major platforms. Newer models from both brands are adding Matter support, which promises simpler pairing across platforms. Check the exact version before ordering, because compatibility is decided by the module inside the box.
Installation: August vs Yale
Installing an August lock means removing the thumb turn on the inside of the door, fitting a mounting plate, and clipping the unit on, a job most people finish in about 10 minutes with a single screwdriver. Your deadbolt, keys, and outside hardware stay untouched. A Yale lock asks more of you: the old lock comes off completely, the new bolt and both side plates go on, and you may need to adjust the door prep if the new bolt sits differently. It is still a job for basic tools, but plan on the better part of an hour.
Subscription Costs: August vs Yale
Neither brand charges a subscription for the basics. Locking and unlocking from the app, creating guest access, and viewing recent activity are free with both. The real costs show up in hardware instead. With August, budget for the separate keypad if you want code entry, and for a bridge if your chosen lock lacks built in WiFi. With Yale, a model sold without a WiFi module may need that module bought later for remote access away from home. Reading the box contents carefully matters more here than comparing app fees, because there are none worth comparing.
Privacy and Security: August vs Yale
Both brands encrypt the connection between the lock, the app, and their cloud services, and both support two factor sign in on the account. Yale brings a long history in physical security, and its smart locks carry solid bolt ratings on many models. August counters with detailed activity logs and automatic locking features that reduce the chance of a door left unsecured. The bigger risk for either brand is account level, not lock level: use a strong password, turn on two factor sign in, and remove guest access when a visitor no longer needs it.
Price and Value
August locks generally cost about $150 to $230, with the keypad and any bridge adding to that total. Yale smart locks run about $150 to $300 depending on finish, keypad style, and whether the WiFi module is included. Value depends on what you would otherwise replace. If your current deadbolt is worn, a Yale lock solves two problems at once. If your deadbolt is new and solid, paying for a full replacement buys you less, and the August route keeps that good hardware working for you.
Which Should You Buy?
Choose August if
- You rent and must hand the door back in its original state
- You want to keep using your existing keys as a backup
- Your building controls how the outside of the door looks
- You want the quickest install with the least risk of fit problems
- You are happy unlocking with your phone and adding a keypad later
Choose Yale if
- You own your home and plan to update the door hardware anyway
- You want entry codes for kids, cleaners, and guests from day one
- Your current deadbolt is worn, sticky, or low quality
- You prefer a keypad on the door instead of relying on phones
- You like the look of a matched, finished lock set
Other Options to Consider
Schlage is the name most often cross shopped against both brands, especially by buyers who want a keypad lock with strong platform support. Our schlage encode plus review looks at the version built for Apple home key fans, while the schlage encode review covers the widely sold WiFi model. If you would rather compare every strong option in one place, start with our guide to the best smart lock picks for each type of door and budget.
FAQs
Is August better than Yale?
Neither brand is better for everyone. August is better when you want minimal change to the door, a fast install, and your old keys still working. Yale is better when you want a complete new lock with codes built in. Because both brands share a parent company, app quality and support feel similar, so the deciding factor is the hardware approach, not the software. Match the approach to your door and household first, then compare the specific models that fit it.
What is the main difference between August and Yale?
The main difference is what happens to your current lock. August keeps it and motorizes it from inside the door, so the project is reversible in minutes. Yale removes it and installs its own bolt and hardware, which is a permanent upgrade. That single choice drives everything else: install time, whether you get a keypad, how the door looks from the street, and whether a landlord would approve. Decide that question first and the rest of the comparison mostly settles itself.
Which is easier to clean, August or Yale?
August is slightly easier to clean because its smooth indoor unit wipes down with a soft cloth and never faces weather. A Yale keypad sits outside, so it collects dust, pollen, and fingerprints, and touchscreen versions show smudges that make worn digits easier to guess over time. Wipe a Yale keypad weekly and change your codes now and then so the wear pattern does not hint at the numbers. Never spray cleaner directly on either lock; dampen the cloth instead.
Which lasts longer, August or Yale?
The hardware from both brands should serve for many years, and batteries are the main consumable, typically lasting a few months per set depending on use. Yale has one edge: its outdoor rated exterior is built to shrug off rain and sun for the long term. August avoids weather entirely indoors, but it inherits the lifespan of the deadbolt it drives, so a cheap, aging deadbolt can become the weak point. Replacing worn door seals helps either lock by cutting the strain on the motor.
Can August or Yale smart locks work in a rental home?
August suits rentals best because it leaves the original lock and keys in place, and you can remove it without marks when you move out. Most landlords still want written permission before any lock change, even a reversible one, so ask first. A Yale lock usually needs landlord approval too, plus agreement on who keeps the codes and spare keys. Whichever brand you choose, keep the original hardware in a labeled bag so restoring the door takes minutes, not a shopping trip.
The Bottom Line
For renters and cautious upgraders, August is the safer path: fast to fit, easy to remove, and gentle on the door. For owners who want codes, fresh hardware, and a finished look, Yale earns its higher effort. Scan the product table above once more, weigh your door and your landlord or household rules, and the right side of the august vs yale smart lock debate will be clear for your home.
